CHAKO Dog Blog

The Official Blog of CHAKO

<June 2006>
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
28293031123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
2526272829301
2345678

Post Categories

News

Visit Our Home page at www.chako.org

Navigation

Subscriptions

Proof that Racism is at the heart of Breed Discrimination

Donald Butler, a member of the Public Safety Committee for Horicon, Wisconsin, believes that Horicon should ban Pit Bulls. His rationale for wanting Pit Bulls out of Horicon is simple, if shockingly discriminatory.

"Horicon is not a ghetto. This is one breed of dogs we do not need."

Many educated dog advocates, attorneys, and scholars have stated that breed discrimination is often a guise for classism. Never before, however, has a public official come right out and admitted such a thing!

We applaud Donald Butler for his bravery. It takes guts to admit that the sole motivation for wanting to get rid of Pit Bulls is because one believes that only "ghetto" people own Pit Bulls. Is it possible that Mr. Butler believes that, by banning Pit Bulls, all the people with darker skin will leave Horicon with their beloved Pit Bulls?

Mr. Butler, despite his bravery, made quite the ass of himself for such assumptions. Even if true, he has shown himself to be a racist, pure and simple. However, Mr. Butler's belief that Pit Bulls are "ghetto" is, of course, erroneous. People like Helen Keller, Michael J. Fox, and John Stewart own Pit Bulls.

The author of this blog happens to hold three degrees and has authored several serious works, including a law review article, a scientific journal article, and a nonfiction book.

Well, if Pit Bulls are "ghetto," then Pit Bulls sure have improved the "ghetto!"

posted on Friday, June 16, 2006 12:01 PM by admin

# re: Proof that Racism is at the heart of Breed Discrimination @ Thursday, January 10, 2008 6:23 PM

Wanting to ban pit bulls because they are "ghetto" does not make Donald Butler a racist. In fact your association of the word "ghetto" with, as you stated, "people with darker skin" is and incorrect usage of the term. A ghetto was originally used to describe an ethnic enclave, but has since been used to designate a high-crime, impoverished neighborhood. No where in the definition of "ghetto," past or present, does it state that residents must be "people with darker skin." While Mr. Butler's choice of words could have been better, he does not state that his primary intent is to drive residents out of Horicon that happen to be, in your words, "people with darker skin," he just feels that pit bulls are a dangerous breed and that their availability should be restricted. This is not class discrimination and this is not racism, if the people of Horicon disagree with his views, than he will be removed/voted out of office during the next election, if not than the people of Horicon obviously agree with the law and it should stand because they have the right to determine their own fate.

holden

Powered by Community Server, by Telligent Systems